Medicare Blog

what happens if i have medicare and refuse hospital discharge

by Willis Skiles II Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago

If you’re on Medicare and you believe your services are ending too soon or you’re receiving discharge orders prematurely, you can ask for a fast appeal to fight the hospital discharge. With a fast appeal, the independent reviewer can determine if your services should continue.

Full Answer

Is there a penalty for refusing Medicare?

You will NOT pay a penalty for delaying Medicare, as long as you enroll within 8 months of losing your coverage or stopping work (whichever happens first).You’ll want to plan ahead and enroll in Part B at least a month before you stop working or your employer coverage ends, so you don’t have a gap in coverage.

What to do if Medicare denies your medical claim?

You can also take other actions to help you accomplish this:

  • Reread your plan rules to ensure you are properly following them.
  • Gather as much support as you can from providers or other key medical personnel to back up your claim.
  • Fill out each form as carefully and exactly as possible. If necessary, ask another person to help you with your claim.

Why do some physicians refuse to accept Medicaid?

When uncovered costs become too great, physicians are ethically justified in refusing to accept Medicaid patients, according to Sade. “If they do accept such patients, however, they are ethically obligated to offer them the same care as they do for all of their patients,” Sade says.

Does Medicare deny procedures?

Suppose you have a hospital stay for a procedure that’s not covered or approved by Medicare. Your Medicare Supplement plan typically wouldn’t cover those costs. So, if Medicare Part A and/or Part B deny a claim for medical services you had or wish to have, generally a Medicare Supplement plan won’t cover it.

Can I refuse to be discharged from hospital?

If you are unhappy with a proposed discharge placement, explain your concerns to the hospital staff, in writing if possible. Ask to speak with the hospital Risk Manager and let them know you are unhappy with your discharge plan. If a hospital proposes an inappropriate discharge, you may refuse to go.

Can a hospital make you discharge?

A hospital will discharge you when you no longer need to receive inpatient care and can go home. Or, a hospital will discharge you to send you to another type of facility. Many hospitals have a discharge planner. This person helps coordinate the information and care you'll need after you leave.

What is Medicare safe discharge policy?

A beneficiary may be considered discharged when Medicare decides it will no longer pay for the medical services or when the physician and hospital believe that medical services are no longer required.

How long can you stay in the hospital under Medicare?

90 daysDoes the length of a stay affect coverage? Medicare covers a hospital stay of up to 90 days, though a person may still need to pay coinsurance during this time. While Medicare does help fund longer stays, it may take the extra time from an individual's reserve days. Medicare provides 60 lifetime reserve days.

What happens if you walk out of a hospital without being discharged?

The AMA label is assigned to a case to protect doctors and the hospital from potential liability. If the patient leaves the hospital before getting the all-clear from the attending physician there is a possibility of an ongoing illness, readmission to the hospital, or even death.

Can a hospital legally keep you?

You can be kept at the hospital against your will if you're a danger to yourself or others because of your mental state. People in this situation are sometimes called involuntary patients. You generally have the same rights as other patients, but some special rules apply.

What happens when Medicare hospital days run out?

Medicare will stop paying for your inpatient-related hospital costs (such as room and board) if you run out of days during your benefit period. To be eligible for a new benefit period, and additional days of inpatient coverage, you must remain out of the hospital or SNF for 60 days in a row.

Who decides hospital discharge?

A hospital discharge planning evaluation is an assessment by the hospital to see if you need a discharge plan. Hospitals must complete an evaluation if a patient requests it. If the evaluation shows you need a discharge plan, the hospital must develop one.

What are the criteria for discharge from hospital?

Results: Experts reached consensus that patients should be considered ready for hospital discharge when there is tolerance of oral intake, recovery of lower gastrointestinal function, adequate pain control with oral analgesia, ability to mobilize and self-care, and no evidence of complications or untreated medical ...

What is the three day rule for Medicare?

The 3-day rule requires the patient have a medically necessary 3-consecutive-day inpatient hospital stay. The 3-consecutive-day count doesn't include the discharge day or pre-admission time spent in the Emergency Room (ER) or outpatient observation.

What is the Medicare two midnight rule?

The Two-Midnight rule, adopted in October 2013 by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, states that more highly reimbursed inpatient payment is appropriate if care is expected to last at least two midnights; otherwise, observation stays should be used.

Does Medicare pay 100 percent of hospital bills?

According to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), more than 60 million people are covered by Medicare. Although Medicare covers most medically necessary inpatient and outpatient health expenses, Medicare reimbursement sometimes does not pay 100% of your medical costs.

Why do hospitals have to discharge patients?

In fact this is the standard protocol for hospitals. Hospitals are under intense pressure to discharge patients as quickly as possible after they are out of immediate danger. This is due to Medicare’s payment policy. Medicare pay hospitals a predetermined fixed amount that is tied to each patient’s diagnosis.

Why appeal a hospital discharge?

Appealing a hospital discharge allows the patient more time to be treated in a hospital and offers the family more time to prepare for home care or to find the right rehab facility.

What is a QIO in Medicare?

Every state has at least one Medicare Quality Improvement Organization , (QIO), that will intervene when a person appeals a hospital discharge. A QIO is a private, usually not-for-profit organization that is staffed by health care professionals who are trained to review medical care and determine if a case has merit.

Can Medicare patients appeal discharge?

Fortunately, Medicare offers a safe recourse—any hospitalized patient covered by Medicare can appeal a hospital discharge. An even greater benefit is the patient can stay in the hospital during the appeal process and continue to be treated at no extra cost.

Can a QIO decide that a patient can be discharged safely?

The good news is, even If the QIO decides that patient can be discharged safely, the patient will not be responsible for paying the hospital charges (except for applicable coinsurance or deductibles). When a patient is first admitted to the hospital he is given a written notice titled “An Important Message from Medicare about Your Rights”. ...

What is hospital discharge?

About the only aspect of leaving a hospital that is consistent among all patients is that we all do it sooner or later. Hospital discharge is the process by which you prepare to leave the hospital . Morsa Images / DigitalVision / Getty Images.

When would a hospital discharge take place?

In an ideal world, hospital discharge would take place when both you and your doctor think the time is right. You would be strong enough and healthy enough to handle not only the important discharge tasks and details, but also to take care of yourself once you arrive at your destination.

What is a QIO in Medicare?

The person you will be appealing to is called the Quality Information Officer (QIO). The federal government has strict requirements for the way a QIO handles discharge appeals. 2 . Ask about the "Safe Discharge" policy . Safe discharge is the key term Medicare uses, and you can use it, too.

How long does Medicare pay for skilled nursing?

For example, if you need to be discharged to a skilled nursing center or rehab, Medicare won’t pay for it unless you’ve stayed at least three days. So you may be caught in a bind. What is wrong with you—based on your diagnostic code—may mean they’ll pay for only two days.

What should a hospital admittance include?

Your hospital admittance should include a statement of your rights along with discharge information and how to appeal a discharge. If you aren’t provided with a notice of discharge and how to file an appeal, request one from the hospital's patient advocate and follow those guidelines. Talk to the QIO.

Does the hospital send you home if you don't pay?

Based on the anticipated codes that have been assigned to you, once your time is up, your payer will no longer pay for your stay. If they won’t pay, then unless you can pay cash, the hospital will send you home. Therefore, your date and time of discharge are not based on physical readiness.

Can you appeal a hospital decision if you are not a Medicare patient?

Medicare has a very specific process to follow no matter where you live or what hospital you’ve been admitted to. Those guidelines may also be used by the hospital for non-Medicare patients, so if you decide to appeal and you aren’t a Medicare patient, you can attempt to try to follow their instructions anyway.

What is the myth about AMA discharge?

One of the most pervasive myths surrounding AMA hospital discharges is that health insurance companies will refuse to pay for associated care and hike up a patient’s premium amounts. This is simply not true, although doctors frequently tell patients who wish to leave AMA that they will be solely responsible for their medical bills if they do so. Surveys have found that a substantial number of residents and attending physicians believe this false information and pass it on to other staff and to patients in an attempt to curtail discharges AMA.

Why label discharges as AMA?

The reason for labelling discharges as AMA serves to protect the hospital and treating physicians from liability if a patient gets sick or dies as a result of their early release. It’s important to discuss all treatment and payment options in detail with the proper staff members to gather all the information needed to make an informed decision.

Why should caregivers be aware of their rights and how AMA discharges work?

Family caregivers and seniors should be aware of their rights and how AMA discharges work to avoid feeling pressured into staying in the hospital or consenting to medical procedures.

What happens if a person is not mentally fit to make medical decisions?

If a person is of sound mind, is not in an altered mental state, and does not pose a threat to themselves or others, they have the right to refuse medical treatment. Psychiatric testing may be required to determine whether a patient lacks mental capacity. If a patient is not fit to make medical decisions for themselves (for example, a senior who has dementia) then their legal representative (medical power of attorney or appointed guardian) is able to make this and other healthcare decisions on their behalf.

Is it bad to leave the hospital against medical advice?

However, refusing treatment in acute care settings and even leaving the hospital against medical advice (AMA) comes with significant risks. There is a great deal of misinformation circulating among patients and even medical professionals like nurses and doctors about hospital discharges against medical advice.

Can you check yourself out of a hospital?

Individuals who have been hospitalized for mental health reasons and pose a threat to themselves and others may not be able to check themselves out of the hospital. And, in emergency scenarios where a patient’s safety or life is at stake, informed consent may be skipped over in order to provide prompt treatment.

Is it bad to leave the AMA?

Studies have shown that patients who leave AMA are at higher risk for early rehospitalization and are therefore likely to incur additional healthcare costs. Even more seriously, those who self-discharge from the hospital experience higher risks of morbidity and mortality.

What to do if you leave a hospital because you are not receiving adequate care?

Addressing Legitimate Complaints. If you decide to leave because you are not receiving adequate care, are in disagreement over your care, or have experienced errors or mistakes that could place your health at risk, do not do so without first lodging an official complaint with the hospital administrator.

What to do if you leave a hospital because you have a bad experience?

On the other hand, if you are leaving because you had a bad experience in the past, are afraid of hospitals, or have fears about methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) or other potential risks, it is important to speak with your doctor and keep an open mind when discussing your concerns.

How much did the number of patients discharged from AMA increase between 1997 and 2011?

In the United States, the total number of patients discharged AMA increased by 41% between 1997 and 2011. 4  Even more surprisingly, the number of patients covered by Medicare who were discharged AMA increased from 25% to 29% between 1997 to 2011.

What is AMA discharge?

In cases where a patient decides to leave against the doctor's recommendations, the case will be labeled a discharge "against medical advice" (AMA). The AMA designation is used in part to help legally shield the doctor and hospital from liability if a patient gets ill ...

Why are AMA discharges declared?

Most evidence suggests that AMA discharges are declared solely for medical reasons and that patients discharged prematur ely are at an increased risk of hospital readmission and even death. 2 . If anything, doctors appear conflicted and largely misinformed about declaring an AMA discharge.

Why do people leave AMA?

One of the most common reasons why people do so is cost. For instance, if you have high-deductible health insurance or are paying cash, every day in the hospital can leave you with mounting medical bills that you would be hard-pressed to afford.

How long does it take for Medicare to readmit a patient?

The Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program (HRRP) under the Affordable Care Act penalizes hospitals if Medicare patients are readmitted within 30 days of their discharge . 1  It was designed to ensure that patients are not released before they are well enough to go home for the completion of their recovery.

How long does a break in SNF last?

"If your break in skilled care lasts more than 30 days, you need a new 3-day hospital stay to qualify for additional SNF care. The new hospital stay doesn’t need to be for ...

Does Medicare cover hospice care?

She may want to go home, but Medicare will cover hospice care there or in a nursing home if she needs to go into the facility (this would be private pay). If she improves under hospice she can go off the program. Listen to what your mom wants. This is her life and she is in a very miserable condition.

What happens after completing rehab?

After completing rehab, many residents are discharged to their home. This is the goal and the hope of everyone involved with Mom’s care. But what if Mom has to remain in the Nursing Home as a private pay resident? Private pay means that she writes a check out of pocket each month for her care until she qualifies to receive Medicaid assistance. Here are a couple of steps to take while Mom is in rehab to determine your best course of action.

How long does Medicare pay for rehab?

When your Loved One is first admitted to rehab, you learn Medi care pays for up to 100 days of care. The staff tells you that during days 1 – 20, Medicare will pay for 100%. For days 21 – 100, Medicare will only pay 80% and the remaining 20% will have to be paid by Mom. However, luckily Mom has a good Medicare supplement policy that pays this 20% co-pay amount. Consequently, the family decides to let Medicare plus the supplement pay. At the end of the 100 days, they will see where they are.

How long did Mom stay in the hospital?

After a 10 day hospital stay, Mom’s doctor told the family that she would need rehabilitative therapy (rehab) to see if she could improve enough to go back home. Mom then started her therapy in the seperate rehab unit of the hospital where she received her initial care.

Can a beneficiary receive Medicare if they are making progress?

A beneficiary can receive Medicare if they simply maintain their current condition or further deterioration is slowed. However, some facilities interpret this policy as reading that “As long as Mom is making progress, we will keep her.”. When she stops making progress, she will be discharged.

Can you receive Medicaid if you gift money 5 years prior?

Financial gifts or transfers from 5 years prior may resulted in a penalty period. This is a period of time during which, even though your Loved One is qualified to receive Medicaid benefits, actual receipt of Medicaid benefits may be delayed to offset any prior gifts (or to use Medicaid’s wording, “uncompensated transfer”).

Can you go home after a rehab stay?

For some folks, it is obvious that they are going home directly after a short rehab stay. For others, like the fictional Mom is our above example, it was not as obvious. However, frequent monitoring of Mom’s care, frequent communication with the staff and tracking her progress or decline should give the family a good idea as to the expected outcome of Mom’s rehab stay.

Executive Summary

  • Patients refusing to leave the hospital for weeks, or even months — despite being medically cleared for discharge — are a growing problem, according to ethicists interviewed by Medical Ethics Advisor. Some ethical considerations include the following: 1. Patients may justifiably fear poor outcomes outside the hospital setting. 2. Other patients in ...
See more on reliasmedia.com

Fairness, Justice Are Issues

  • Taking up an ICU or acute care rehab bed when a less intense, less costly care setting is appropriate “raises a serious issue of fairness and justice in how we utilize medical resources,” says Wayne Shelton, PhD, professor at the Alden March Bioethics Institute at Albany (NY) Medical College. Keeping someone in the hospital who is ready for discharge prevents other patients in n…
See more on reliasmedia.com

‘Nuts and Bolts’ of Discharge

  • Robert N. Swidler, Esq, vice president of legal services for St. Peter’s Health Partners in Albany, NY, has authored several papers on difficult discharges.3,4He says the following ethical questions should be considered involving the decision to discharge over the objections of the patient or family: 1. How much weight should be given to the patient or family member’s preference to sta…
See more on reliasmedia.com

References

  1. Gluck F. Lee Memorial sues to evict another ‘John Doe’ patient. News-Press, June 2, 2016. http://newspr.es/2r3lNcD.
  2. Stuart C. Hospital Asks Leave to Boot Cranky Patient. Courthouse News Service, Oct. 18, 2013. http://bit.ly/2r2KNkh.
  3. Jankowski J, Seatrum T, Swidler R, et al. For lack of a better plan: A framework for ethical, leg…
  1. Gluck F. Lee Memorial sues to evict another ‘John Doe’ patient. News-Press, June 2, 2016. http://newspr.es/2r3lNcD.
  2. Stuart C. Hospital Asks Leave to Boot Cranky Patient. Courthouse News Service, Oct. 18, 2013. http://bit.ly/2r2KNkh.
  3. Jankowski J, Seatrum T, Swidler R, et al. For lack of a better plan: A framework for ethical, legal and clinical challenges in complex inpatient discharge planning. HEC Forum 2009; 21(4):311-326.
  4. Swidler R, Barreiro A, Horwitz J, et al. A conversation about difficult inpatient discharge decisions. NYS Bar Assn Health Law J2009; 14:108-125.

Sources

  1. Julie M. Aultman, PhD, Director, Bioethics Program/Professor, Department of Family and Community Medicine, Northeast Ohio Medical University, Rootstown. Phone: (330) 325-6113. Fax: (330) 325-5911....
  2. John D. Banja, PhD, Center for Ethics, Emory University, Atlanta. Phone: (404) 712-4804. Fax: (404) 727-7399. Email: [email protected].
  1. Julie M. Aultman, PhD, Director, Bioethics Program/Professor, Department of Family and Community Medicine, Northeast Ohio Medical University, Rootstown. Phone: (330) 325-6113. Fax: (330) 325-5911....
  2. John D. Banja, PhD, Center for Ethics, Emory University, Atlanta. Phone: (404) 712-4804. Fax: (404) 727-7399. Email: [email protected].
  3. Cheyn Onarecker, MD, MA, Director, Family Medicine Residency Program, St. Anthony Hospital, Oklahoma City. Phone: (405) 272-7494. Email: [email protected].
  4. Wayne Shelton, PhD, Professor, Alden March Bioethics Institute, Albany (NY) Medical College. Phone: (518) 262-6423. Fax: (518) 262-6856. Email: [email protected].

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9