Full Answer
Are Social Security and Medicare entitlements?
And as of this writing, a Google search pulls up numerous recent instances of recent letters-to-the-editor, such as this one at the East Oregonian ("The GOP leadership has started referring to Social Security and Medicare as “entitlements” . . . but . . . these are benefits we have earned and paid for with deductions from our paychecks . . . .
When did a citizen become entitled to Social Security and Medicare?
Citizens became entitled to Social Security checks and Medicare healthcare insurance coverage almost immediately after the relevant legislation was passed into law: 1935 [ 1] for Social Security (the first check being written in 1937) and 1965 [ 2] for Medicare.
Why do some people call Social Security an entitlement?
They can call it that because Social Security is an entitlement — literally. And I think you've got to blame popular culture, not politicians, for abusing the term. Social Security is an entitlement in not only the literal but also the legal sense of the term. Social Security is Title II of the Social Security Act.
What is the definition of entitlements as it applies to Medicare?
The definition of entitlements as it applies to Social Security and Medicare is: A government program providing benefits to any person meeting certain requirements. Since both Social Security and Medicare are government programs and they provide benefits to people who meet certain criteria,...
Who made Social Security an entitlement?
President Franklin Roosevelt would choose the social insurance approach as the "cornerstone" of his attempts to deal with the problem of economic security. On June 8, 1934, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, in a message to the Congress, announced his intention to provide a program for Social Security.
Are Social Security and Medicare considered entitlements?
The Social Security benefit programs are “entitlement” programs. This means that workers, employers and the self-employed pay for the benefits with their Social Security taxes. The taxes that are collected are put into special trust funds.
Who is responsible for Social Security and Medicare?
State and local government employees who are covered by Social Security and Medicare pay into these programs and have the same rights as workers in the private sector. Each state has a designated official, called the State Social Security Administrator, who is responsible for the state's Section 218 agreement.
Why Social Security is not an entitlement?
Congress contractually, will need to take steps to shore up Social Security's finances, as it did in 1983, the last time the fund nearly depleted its funds. Social Security is binding contract between our government and its citizens. It is not an entitlement!
What is considered an entitlement program?
Entitlement programs are either financed from Federal trust funds or paid out of the general revenues. Those paid out of the general revenues are income redistribution programs intended to address problems such as illness and poverty.
Which of the following are considered entitlement programs?
Entitlement Programs of the federal government include Medicaid, Medicare, Social Security, Unemployment, and welfare programs. Entitlement programs are rights granted to citizens and certain non-citizens by federal law.
What president took money from the Social Security fund?
President Lyndon B. Johnson1.STATEMENT BY THE PRESIDENT UPON MAKING PUBLIC THE REPORT OF THE PRESIDENT'S COUNCIL ON AGING--FEBRUARY 9, 19647.STATEMENT BY THE PRESIDENT COMMENORATING THE 30TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE SIGNING OF THE SOCIAL SECURITY ACT -- AUGUST 15, 196515 more rows
Which president messed up Social Security?
President Richard M. Nixon1.SPECIAL MESSAGE TO THE CONGRESS ON SOCIAL SECURITY -- SEPTEMBER 25, 19694.STATEMENT ABOUT APPROVAL OF THE WELFARE REFORM AND SOCIAL SECURITY BILL BY THE HOUSE COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS--MAY 18, 197119 more rows
Which president changed Social Security?
President ReaganThis change was in fact enacted into statute in the Social Security Amendments of 1983, signed into law by President Reagan on April 20, 1983. The actual form of the 1983 change was somewhat complex.
Is Social Security a right or privilege?
You're legally entitled to Social Security benefits, right? Wrong. There is no legal right to Social Security, and that is one of the considerations that may decide the coming debate over Social Security reform.
What is the difference between a benefit and an entitlement?
So, by definition, things like sick pay and holiday parties are benefits. Workers' compensation and unemployment insurance are entitlements. That would clearly put coffee in the benefit category.
What is an entitlement benefit?
entitlement, generally, any government-provided or government-managed benefit or service to which some or all individuals are entitled by law. The term is also but less frequently applied to benefits provided by employers to employees unilaterally or as mandated by law or by contract (see fringe benefit).
Do people pay for Medicare?
Most people do not pay for all of their Medicare benefits, but rather pay for a small portion towards them. The gap between what people pay into Medicare and what they receive in benefits, is, in fact, the largest source of the country’s fiscal problem.
Does Medicare and Social Security contribute to the country's fiscal problems?
According to Leonhardt, there is no reading of the budget that support the liberal view that Social Security and Medicare do not contribute to the country’s fiscal problems . He believes that if they are left unchanged, they will create large deficits.
What is the title of Medicare?
Medicare is Title XVIII — and other programs make up other titles of the Social Security law. So that's where the root word "title" comes from. Once you meet all the qualifications for Social Security benefits (having enough work credits, being the right age, etc.) then you are considered eligible for benefits.
How much did you pay in Social Security taxes in 2011?
Assuming, as you said, that you paid Social Security taxes on maximum earnings from 1971 to 2011, you will have paid $132,740 in Social Security taxes during those 40 years. At $2,400 per month in retirement benefits, you will recoup all the taxes you paid in about 55 months, or a little more than 4 1/2 years.
Is Social Security an entitlement?
And I think you've got to blame popular culture, not politicians, for abusing the term. Social Security is an entitlement in not only the literal but also the legal sense of the term. Social Security is Title II of the Social Security Act.
Was Social Security an investment scheme?
But here is some food for thought. You must remember that Social Security was never set up to be an investment scheme. One of the original objectives of Social Security was to try to strike a balance between what you get out of the program and what the country gets out of it.
Is Medicare a part of Social Security?
Medicare is a completely separate program and is entirely separately funded. It makes absolutely no sense to factor in Medicare taxes when trying to figure out Social Security payback times. OK, so here are the numbers.
Who wrote the complaint about entitlements?
A New York City reader, Judith Abrams, wrote with a complaint about the use of the term “entitlements” in federal budget articles. In so doing, she raised other questions that are worth consideration.
Who is Liz Spayd?
Liz Spayd is the sixth public editor appointed by The New York Times. The public editor works outside of the reporting and editing structure of the newspaper and receives and answers questions or comments from readers and the public, principally about news and other coverage in The Times. Her opinions and conclusions are her own. Read more »
What is entitlement program?
On the first point: While "entitlement program" has become a pejorative phrase in some circles, with the insinuation that people are getting something they didn't earn, it's really just a term for any government program guaranteeing certain benefits to a segment of the population.
Who wrote the column entitled "The biggest income redistribution in the United States is not from the rich to the
It's from younger taxpayers to retirees. This opinion column was written by Julie Mack. for the Kalamazoo Gazette.
Is Medicare a redistribution?
That bring us to the second point: Social Security and Medicare are not just entitlement programs, they also are very much an example of redistribution. Sure, American workers pay a specific tax to fund the Social Security and Medicare systems, and Social Security benefits are correlated to work history and earnings.
What is Medicare and Social Security called?
Thus Social Security and Medicare are called entitlements, and they are the largest programs in the category. When people refer in passing to 'reforming entitlements' they are usually talking about these two programs.
How many times has NPR used entitlements?
Even in the week and a half since Congress reached a deal, NPR hosts, correspondents and on-air guests have used the term "entitlement" or "entitlements" 24 times referring to the governmental programs.
Is Medicaid an entitlement?
Medicaid could be fairly called an entitlement. But it is prejudicial to the argument when the larger programs are referred to as something that sounds undeserved.". "Isn't it time for NPR to stop referring to medicare and social security as 'entitlements'?". asked Dorothy Slater, from Denver, CO.
How much money did Pelosi take from Medicare?
A bill that the Pelosi-led House passed in late June would take $448.2 billion in Medicare savings to fund additional Obamacare subsidies.
Did Obamacare hurt Medicare?
In reality, the law worsened Medicare’s fiscal future. By taking funds out of Medicare to pay for new entitlements, Obamacare diverted funds that could have improved the program’s financial soundness and stability. Worse yet, Democrats claimed that these savings would both extend Medicare’s solvency and fund Obamacare.
Did the Democrats take Medicare to pay for Obamacare?
The Democrats Raided Medicare to Pay for Obamacare. You don’t have to take my word for it on this one — House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) admitted it herself. In a 2011 interview with CNBC, she said that Democrats “took half a trillion dollars out of Medicare” to fund Obamacare.
Widely Cited
- The Times is one of the first major news organizations to take a firm stand against a growing and disliked practice. The Times has dismantled its environmental pod and discontinued the Green blog. The public editor looks into a test drive of an electric car that caused a storm. The statistical wizard's offer to wager on the outcome of the president...
Government Secrecy and Bradley Manning
- Those who reveal classified material are being punished like never before. When the government asks newspapers to keep quiet, the bar should be very high for saying yes. Editors were asked by the C.I.A. to withhold information and did so for months before publishing it online Tuesday night. Scott Shane, a Times national security reporter, was referred to in the government’s prosecution …
False Balance and Objectivity in Reporting
- The public editor travels to Harvard’s Shorenstein Center. With audio. Is the concept outdated or even more important in the new media era? The journalistic ideal of impartiality is coming under attack. My column for this week. The public editor speaks with Times editors about how they plan to fact-check the first presidential debate. When opinion appears in news pages, it needs to be l…
Language and Semantics
- The Times is reconsidering the use of the term "illegal immigrant." An article coyly wrote around a business name that used an unprintable word according to The Times's standards. A crisis in North Africa and a reader’s query bring up crucial distinctions in usage. Families are rightfully upset by some of the early reporting done on the Newtown, Conn., shootings. The research and …
Gender, Race and Ethnicity
- After criticism on Twitter and elsewhere, the first sentence of an obituary for Yvonne Brill was changed. A front-page article involving the New York Police Department's internal communication could have provided greater context. A headline ignites a discussion about its "undermining" question. News organizations should evaluate the motivations of parents who want to take thei…
Culture Criticism
- Michael Kimmelman views architecture in terms of public policy as well as aesthetics. The criticism of a new restaurant in Times Square was delicious, even if the food was not. The critic Pete Wells gave his first “poor” restaurant rating in The Times -- and he did it memorably. Cathy Horyn's work can't please everyone -- but this is ridiculous.