Medicare Blog

why are social security and medicare wages different from box 1

by Coby Larkin I Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago
image

Here are a few common reasons for differences between Box 1 wages vs. Social Security wages, Medicare wages, and state and local income wages: 1. The employee elected to contribute to a retirement plan If an employee elected to contribute to a pre-tax retirement plan, their W-2 Box 1 wages are likely lower than their Box 3 wages.

Full Answer

Why are my Box 1 wages different than other wages?

Here are a few common reasons for differences between Box 1 wages vs. Social Security wages, Medicare wages, and state and local income wages: 1. The employee elected to contribute to a retirement plan

What's the difference between Box 1 and Box 3 on W2?

But Box 1 can also be greater than Box 3, since Box 3 (social security wages) is capped at $118,500 of income (for 2016). After that, no additional social security tax is withheld. Box 5 (medicare wages) is not capped. June 5, 2019 10:38 PM Income w-2 what should the difference be between box 1 and box 3 and which should be a larger number?

How are Social Security and Medicare taxable wages calculated on W-2?

To determine Social Security and Medicare taxable wages on your W-2, again begin with the Gross Pay YTD from your final pay stub and make the following adjustments if applicable: Subtract the following:

Why is box 3 greater than box 1 on my taxes?

Most commonly, you'll see Box 3 greater than Box 1, which is -- as you thought -- a result of subtracting pre-tax items such as retirement plan deferrals. But Box 1 can also be greater than Box 3, since Box 3 (social security wages) is capped at $118,500 of income (for 2016). After that, no additional social security tax is withheld.

image

Why are Social Security wages and Medicare wages different?

The most common questions relate to why W-2 Wages differ from your final pay stub for the year, and why Federal and State Wages per your W-2 differ from Social Security and Medicare Wages per the W-2. The short answer is that the differences relate to what wage amounts are taxable in each case.

Are Medicare wages the same as Social Security wages?

Box 1 (Wages, Tips and Other Compensation) represents the amount of compensation taxable for federal income tax purposes while box 3 (Social Security Wages) represents the portion taxable for social security purposes and box 5 (Medicare Wages) represents the portion taxable for Medicare tax purposes.

Why are Medicare wages higher than Box 1 wages?

There is no maximum wage base for Medicare taxes. The amount shown in Box 5 may be larger than the amount shown in Box 1. Medicare wages include any deferred compensation, retirement contributions, or other fringe benefits that are normally excluded from the regular income tax.

Why is Social Security income higher than wages on w2?

Your social security wages can be higher than your wages if you are making contributions to a 401k plan or have other items taken out of your check "pre-tax". You are paying social security tax on these items but not income tax.

Why is Box 1 on my W-2 less than my salary?

If your Box 1, W-2 amount is less than your salary, it is because you have pre-tax deductions from your salary under one or more employer plans. If you are not sure about your Box 1 amount, your payroll department can provide the details of the calculation of your Box 1 amount.

Should Social Security wages be the same as wages?

Social Security wages are not the same as gross income. While the amount of Social Security wages and gross income are often identical, they just as easily may not be. Gross income is the total of all compensation from which the amount of taxes and other withholdings are calculated.

Do Social Security and Medicare tax count as federal withholding?

Social Security taxes will not reduce the amount of federal income taxes that you owe since they are separate. However, if you end up with excess Social Security taxes withheld, you'd get a refund on your tax return that you could put toward paying any federal income taxes due.

What are Social Security and Medicare wages?

The current tax rate for social security is 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, or 12.4% total. The current rate for Medicare is 1.45% for the employer and 1.45% for the employee, or 2.9% total.

What is included in Box 1 wages?

Box 1 "Wages, tips, other compensation": This is federal, taxable income for payments in the calendar year. The amount is calculated as YTD earnings minus pre- tax retirement and pre-tax benefit deductions plus taxable benefits (i.e., certain educational benefits).

Why is box 1 and 3 different on my W-2?

Some pre-tax deductions reduce your taxable income (box 1) and your social security income (box 3). Other pre-tax deductions only reduce your taxable income (box 1). If you have a deduction that only reduces your taxable income then the amounts in box 1 and box 3 will be different.

Why are my Social Security wages less than my salary?

Box 3: Social Security Wages. Social Security wages are reduced by pre-tax deductions such as health/dental/vision insurances, parking and flex spending but not reduced by your contributions to a retirement plan (403b or 457.)

Why is Box 1 higher than box 5 W-2?

Box 5 reports the amount of wages subject to the Medicare Tax. There is no maximum wage base for Medicare, so the amount showing in Box 5 may be larger than the amount showing in Box 1. It is quite common for Boxes 3 and 5 to be higher than Box 1.

What is Box 2 in Social Security?

Box 2 shows how much federal income tax you withheld from Box 1 wages throughout the year. The numbers in Box 1 and Box 2 help determine an employee’s tax refund or liability. Most benefits that are exempt from federal income tax are not exempt from Social Security tax.

Why are boxes 1 and 3 different?

Because some benefits are not subject to federal income tax, Boxes 1 and 3 (as well as Box 5) can have different values. Likewise, you may see W-2 Box 1 and Box 16 differ. And, the values in Box 1 and Box 18 may also vary.

What box do you report taxable wages in 2020?

Let’s say you pay an employee $150,000 in taxable wages in 2020. You would enter “$150,000” in Box 1 and “$137,700” in Box 3. Because there is no Medicare wage base, you must also report “$150,000” in Box 5.

What is box 1 in the IRS?

Box 1—wages, tips, other compensation—contains an employee’s total wages subject to federal income tax. Do not include pre-tax benefits in Box 1. Per the IRS, list the following taxable wages, tips, and other compensation in Box 1: Total wages, bonuses, prizes, and awards you paid an employee. Noncash payments.

What are the boxes for retirement contributions?

Other states tax contributions at the state level. If retirement contributions are exempt from state income tax, Boxes 1 and 16 may be the same. If contributions are subject to state income tax, Box 16 may be higher than Box 1.

Do you report earnings above SS tax?

After an employee earns above the Social Security wage base, they no longer need to pay Social Security tax. Because earnings above the Social Security wage base aren’t subject to SS tax, don’t report them in Box 3.

Is Box 16 higher than Box 1?

If contributions are subject to state income tax, Box 16 may be higher than Box 1. For example, Pennsylvania requires employees to pay state income tax on retirement contributions. On the other hand, Ohio aligns itself with federal requirements and exempts retirement contributions from state income tax.

Your employee earns tips

An employee who earns tips may also have different amounts in Boxes 1, 3, and 5. This is because tips are included in the amounts in boxes 1 and 5. They are separated out in box 3 and box 7 for Social Security.

Your employee is exempt from one or more Federal taxes

There are several types of employees who are not subject to some Federal taxes per IRS rules. Clergy, employees on a work Visa, and some family members of business owners are a few examples.

I think I was scammed by a Best Buy employee

Me and my mother went to Best Buy to pick out this 85in Samsung for my Dad for Christmas. The girl at the register told us that her system wasn’t working but the store was actively accepting PayPal/Venmo payments for products. She then held out a iPhone and told us to pay using the PayPal QR code.

I am 23. My parents are 61 (mom) and 57 (dad). They have no savings, no retirement, and dad brings home less than I do. I am stressed and don't know what to do

Dad made great money growing up, until I was 12. Then he was unemployed for a while, but mom wanted to continue living in the $2300/month home and buy stuff, and dad was/is an alcoholic and a heavy smoker (he's quit smoking now, yay!) So a lot of money was just being wasted.

Bank can't tell me what my balance is on a 30 year old account

My wife's father passed away and she's closing on selling his house. Everything was fine until the bank said there's an unpaid credit line they discovered on public record. The credit line was taken out on the house 30 years ago, with a company that since went out of business and (maybe?) sold the credit to another company.

Is a std insurance worth it?

My new job is offering std. it’s $4.18 a pay check for 20% or 12.48 for 60%. I am looking to start trying for kids within this next year. Tbh I had also thought maternity leave was paid for through the employer but I’m reading that it is actually std covers this? Anyone more familiar with this?

Avoid Rocket Mortgage

Another horrible experience with them. Dragged on for months, gave me excuses on they couldn’t reach me for documents while both app and the initial sales rep had no problem getting hold of me before I fork over $500 app fee.

Ally Bank sent me someone's social security number..

About two week ago I got a letter from Ally about backup withholding taking place on my account. The issue is, while the address on the envelope was mine, the name on the envelope was not. When I opened it my name was in the body of the letter, and below it was a social security number which was not mine.

Small hospital bill went to collections

I have a $75 bill that went to collections, and not sure how to proceed. I’ve read everything online from, just ‘pay it off right away’, to ‘don’t ever pay a collection agency’. My concern is not the amount, but what I’ve heard about collections possibly racking on late fees, and the possibility of it being fraudulent.

What are the boxes on a W-2?

Boxes 1, 3, 5, 16, and 18 are all wages boxes on the W-2 form. However, these wages don't always correspond to an employee's gross wages from their final paycheck. This may confuse employees whose annual salaries and W-2 wage reporting don't match.

Is Section 125 pretax?

Section 125 Health/Dental/Vision/AFLAC or HSA items are pretax, meaning they reduce the employee's taxable wages by the amounts deducted. This applies to all tax types: OASDI/Social Security, Medicare, federal income, state income, and most local taxes.

What to call if your W-2 does not match Social Security?

If you find that after making these adjustments to your Gross Pay YTD per your final pay stub, the result does not match Box 3 Social Security Wages and Box 5 Medicare Wages on your W-2, call Central Payroll, 617-495-8500, option 4 for assistance.

What to call if your W-2 does not match Box 1?

If you find that after making these adjustments to your Gross Pay YTD per your final pay stub, the result does not match Box 1 Federal Wages and Box 16 State Wages on your W-2, call Central Payroll, 617-495-8500, option 4, for assistance.

What is the Social Security base for 2019?

The Social Security Wage Base for 2019 was $132,900. To determine Social Security and Medicare taxable wages on your W-2, again begin with the Gross Pay YTD from your final pay stub and make the following adjustments if applicable:

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9