why do republicans want to phase out medicare

Why did only one Republican vote against Medicare?

Though Republicans supported it, no Democrat in Congress would agree and the balance was such the Republicans had to convince at least one Senator to switch sides. When Medicare was first being considered Senate Republican Robert Dole (then in the House) voted against it.

Does the Senate Republicans’ plan end Social Security and Medicare?

The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee claimed that the "Senate Republicans’ plan" would "end Social Security" and "end Medicare." The ad refers not to a plan from Senate Republicans but from one Republican, Scott. The plan would sunset all federal laws after five years, requiring Congress to renew the laws it wants to keep.

Should the Democratic Party expand Social Security and Medicare?

The Democratic Party must stand clearly and forcefully in favor of expanding, not cutting, Social Security and Medicare. If the Democratic Party can draw a clear distinction on this vital issue, it can create a powerful wedge between the Republican elites and their base.

What would happen to Medicare and Medicaid if Congress reversed Obamacare?

Congress would have to renew the laws it wants to keep. As the New York Times reported: "Taken literally, that would leave the fate of Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security to the whims of a Congress that rarely passes anything so expansive."

Who was the president who criticized Medicare?

When Medicare was being debated in the early 1960s, one of its most prominent opponents was a certain future president, who recorded a spoken word album called Ronald Reagan Speaks Out Against Socialized Medicine. In it, he said that if the bill were to pass, "We are going to spend our sunset years telling our children and our children's children what it once was like in America when men were free." He failed in that crusade, and ever since, conservatives have watched in pain as the program became more entrenched and more popular.

How to identify a politician's sincere convictions?

One way you can identify politicians' sincere convictions is by looking at the things they do even when they know they're unpopular. There are few better examples than the half-century-long quest by Republicans to destroy Medicare.

Will Republicans give up Medicare?

Republicans won't give up. They want to undermine Medicare, to privatize it, to try in whatever way they can come up with to hasten the day when it disappears. And no matter how often they fail, they keep trying.

Is Medicare a disaster?

In other words: Medicare is a disaster, but we would never change it for the people who are on it and love it so much. They don't have to fear the horror of being subject to our plan for Medicare's future. Which is going to be great.

How much did Medicare cut in 2018?

Congressional Republicans proposed these cuts after passing a budget resolution last year that cut Medicare by $473 billion. The 2018 budget resolution passed by Republicans in December 2017 cut Medicare by $473 billion.

Did the ACA repeal the Medicare?

Congressional Republicans repealed several components of the ACA designed to help keep Medicare’s costs down, effectively driving up costs for the program. By repealing the requirement that most people have insurance, Congressional Republicans knowingly voted for a measure expected to increase the number of uninsured. The 2018 Medicare Trustees Report predicts that this increase will increase the share of subsidies paid to hospitals via Medicare. Similarly, by repealing the Independent Payment Advisory Board, Congressional Republicans took away a mechanism that slowed Medicare cost growth.

Can Medicare negotiate with drug manufacturers?

As the cost of drugs skyrocket, President Trump and his Republican allies in Congress will not allow Medicare to negotiate for better prescription drug prices. Under current law, the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is explicitly prohibited from negotiating directly with drug manufacturers on behalf of Medicare Part D enrollees. Although it would decrease both federal spending and beneficiaries’ out-of-pocket costs for prescription drugs, a policy allowing the federal government to negotiate drug prices for Medicare beneficiaries was noticeably absent from President Trump’s recent prescription drug announcement.

Why do Republicans hate Medicare?

Because Social Security and Medicare are government programs that work so well, the Republican elite — with its seemingly religious belief that the private sector is always the best — hates them . So obsessed are the Republicans in their desire to eliminate these effective government programs that the very first action that House Republicans took in the new Congress was to adopt a rules package that included a new rule that amounts to a stealth attack on Social Security and Medicare.

What are the Republicans' obsessions with Medicare?

The Republican Obsession With Dismantling Social Security And Medicare. Today’s Republicans want to avoid political accountability by destroying Social Security and Medicare without leaving clear fingerprints. The Republicans are desperate to destroy Social Security and Medicare. These two programs demonstrate government at its best.

What is the Republican claim that they are simply seeking to save Social Security and Medicare?

Republican claims that they are simply seeking to save Social Security and Medicare is the same Orwellian language used during the Vietnam War, when a military officer claimed that a village had to be destroyed in order to save it. Similarly, when today’s Republicans talk of “saving” Social Security and Medicare, ...

Why don't Social Security and Medicare go through the appropriations process?

Social Security — the people’s pension — and Medicare — the first step toward universal health insurance for all — do not go through the appropriations process because, as monthly pension payments and medical insurance, they must pay what is owed, not what Congress chooses to spend. If Social Security and Medicare were subject to the whims of every Congress, they would be radically transformed. No one could count on the benefits they had earned. Presumably with that goal in mind, the new rules require the relevant committees to make “recommendations for changes to existing law for moving [unspecified} programs…from mandatory funding to discretionary appropriations, where appropriate.”

Why does Medicare not go through the appropriations process?

Social Security — the people’s pension — and Medicare — the first step toward universal health insurance for all — do not go through the appropriations process because, as monthly pension payments and medical insurance, they must pay what is owed, not what Congress chooses to spend. If Social Security and Medicare were subject to the whims ...

What are the two programs that Republicans want to destroy?

The Republicans are desperate to destroy Social Security and Medicare. These two programs demonstrate government at its best. The federal government runs these two extremely popular programs more efficiently, universally, securely, and effectively than the private sector does with its alternatives — or indeed could, ...

What would happen if the Democratic Party could draw a clear distinction on this vital issue?

If the Democratic Party can draw a clear distinction on this vital issue, it can create a powerful wedge between the Republican elites and their base. If the base catches on and realizes who truly represents their economic interests, the next four years, difficult as they are going to be, will be followed by important progress for many years to come.

Who voted against Medicare?

When Medicare was first being considered Senate Republican Robert Dole (then in the House) voted against it. Also in opposition to Medicare, in a famous 1964 speech, Ronald Reagan explained that his opposition to Social Security and Medicare is why he switched from the Democratic Party to the Republican Party.

What percentage of Americans would prefer to reverse the Republican tax cuts?

A poll one week before the election about Republican social and economic policy is a red flag for Republicans. 60% of Americans would prefer to reverse the Republican 2017 tax cuts than cut spending on Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.

Why did McConnell say the Republicans would defend the tax cuts?

This poll was taken a week after Senator McConnell said the Republicans would defend the tax cuts and cut Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid in order to curb the growing deficit, caused in significant part by those very tax cuts. The Republican Party has always been associated with opposition to Social Security.

Which party is opposed to Social Security?

The Republican Party has always been associated with opposition to Social Security. Economic historian Max Skidmore shows that the final vote for Social Security was lopsided--only 2% of Democrats voted against it (because it wasn't generous enough) while 33% of Republicans voted against Social Security.

Who is calling for cuts to Social Security?

Not only is President Trump arguing with leading Republican Paul Ryan, about the Constitution, but the highest-ranking Republican in the Senate – Senator Mitch McConnell -- has called for cuts to Social Security. That is strange politics because Social Security is the most popular program in America, especially among the voters who are growing the fastest and who vote the most – people over 65.

Is Social Security a fiscal discipline?

Social Security is one of the few government programs with built-in fiscal discipline. Bottom Line: Though Senator McConnell may not have meant to publicize the Republican agenda to cut Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, the long history of Republican opposition may be an example of what Sigmund Freud and modern psychologists believe--a slip ...

Who is the highest ranking Republican in the Senate?

Not only is President Trump arguing with leading Republican Paul Ryan, about the Constitution, but the highest-ranking Republican in the Senate – Senator Mitch McConnell -- has called for cuts to Social Security.

When did the Cares Act expire?

The pandemic-related deficits are mainly temporary. Congress enacted the CARES Act in March 2020, which offered temporary relief mainly to families, unemployed workers and closed business. Most of its provisions expired in the second half of 2020. The newly elected Congress then enacted the American Rescue Plan in March 2021.

What are the immediate benefits of a tax increase?

The immediate benefits are less inequality and better health outcomes, both of which ultimately support stronger economic growth. Improving revenues for these programs by, for example, increasing payroll taxes on the top income earners will ultimately result in stronger growth and shrinking federal deficits.

What are the temporary fiscal interventions of 2020 and 2021?

The temporary fiscal interventions of 2020 and 2021, which the senators opposed, provide a much higher bang for the buck than the long-term budget busting trickle-down tax cuts of 2017, which many supported.

What was Donald Trump's signature legislative achievement?

Donald Trump’s signature legislative achievement was the Tac Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. It showered trillions of dollars on highly profitable corporations and the richest American households that had seen the largest economic gains in the wake of the Great Recession from 2007 to 2009. Moreover, many provisions of this tax legislation are now permanent fixtures of the tax code and many temporary ones, such as tax cuts for high-income earners will likely become permanent, if past supply-side tax cuts are any indication.

Is the program cutting push for a balanced budget wrong?

The program-cutting push for a balanced budget ignores two key aspects of fiscal policy. First, it matters whether fiscal interactions create temporary or permanent deficits and second, it matters whether the spending or tax cuts underlying the deficits resulted in faster growth. On both counts, using the pandemic-related fiscal measures to justify cuts for Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid is wrong.

Does the Cares Act help the economy?

In contrast, the CARES Act offered much needed relief amid the worst unemployment crisis since the Great Depression, while it helped to stem the tide on declining economic growth. And experts predict that ARPA will boost economic growth to its highest rate in decades.

Will the Federal Reserve keep interest rates low?

The Federal Reserve will also likely keep interest rates low for some time. Congress will eventually need to worry about the long-term health of the U.S. government, but that does not mean a balanced budget, especially one that is achieved by cutting only vital programs.

Scott’s ’11-Point Plan’

Other Democratic Attacks

• On April 28, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee tweetedthat the “Senate Republicans’ plan would END” Social Security. The tweet includes a video that starts with an edited clip of Fox News anchor John Roberts asking Scott about his plan. “You recently put out an 11-point plan to rescue America,” Roberts said. “That would raise taxes on ha...

See more on factcheck.org

Scott on Social Security, Medicare