Medicare Blog

why dont politicians address deficit debt social security and medicare

by Manuela Koelpin Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago
image

Do Social Security payments add to the federal deficit?

Social Security payments do not add to the federal deficit or debt, despite conservative politicians’ claims. By law, Social Security is self-sustaining with its own funding – the payroll taxes collected from every working American – and cannot spend money (Social Security benefits) it doesn’t have.

What's the difference between Republican and Democratic plans to privatize Social Security?

Republicans have proposed privatizing the program, allowing (or requiring) each American to be responsible for his or her own investment success, while Democrats view such efforts as a backdoor attempt to gut the essence of the guaranteed benefits.

Do Republicans think the national debt is a threat to America?

Basically, having created the massive deficit, Republicans actually don’t really think it’s a big deal right now, either. But you can bet that if Trump loses and a Democratic president tries to enact a new social program, Republicans will be saying the national debt is a threat to the country.

How is social security like a lake?

The Social Security program is analogous to a large lake that provides water to a community. The lake is created when excess rain is collected, the level of water moving up or down as rain falls or people draw the water.

image

What is the relationship between Social Security and the federal deficit and debt?

By law, Social Security cannot contribute to the federal deficit, because it is required to pay benefits only from its trust funds. Those, in turn, are funded through a dedicated payroll tax of 12.4 percent of income, split evenly between employees and employers, levied on income (this year) up to $128,400.

How much is the government in debt from Social Security?

The largest holding of intragovernmental debt is the $2.8 trillion in Social Security's retirement and disability trust funds.

Why do Social Security and Medicare pose problems for the federal government budget?

There are 3 main reasons why these two programs are problematic to our government: The worker-to-retiree ratio is decreasing. The life expectancy of people retiring is increasing. The total number of retirees is increasing annually.

Does Social Security have anything to do with deficit?

Despite the implication of its off-budget status, Social Security spending and revenues affect annual net deficit measurements. Under the unified budget, Social Security surpluses reduce total annual deficits (i.e., the surpluses are subtracted from the general account deficit).

Which president started borrowing from Social Security?

President Lyndon B. Johnson1.STATEMENT BY THE PRESIDENT UPON MAKING PUBLIC THE REPORT OF THE PRESIDENT'S COUNCIL ON AGING--FEBRUARY 9, 19647.STATEMENT BY THE PRESIDENT COMMENORATING THE 30TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE SIGNING OF THE SOCIAL SECURITY ACT -- AUGUST 15, 196515 more rows

Did Congress borrow money from the Social Security fund?

The federal government hasn't pilfered a dime from Social Security. The fact is that Congress, despite borrowing $2.9 trillion from Social Security, hasn't pilfered or misappropriated a red cent from the program. Regardless of whether Social Security was presented as a unified budget under Lyndon B.

What year did the federal government borrow money from Social Security?

In other words, the borrowing fund was required to make the loaning fund whole at the end of the process. This authority was used twice, once in November 1982 and once in December 1982. The total amount borrowed was $17.5 billion.

What is the largest source of federal revenue from taxes?

individual income taxesThis is especially important as the economic recovery from the pandemic continues. In the United States, individual income taxes (federal, state, and local) were the primary source of tax revenue in 2020, at 41.1 percent of total tax revenue.

How does the government deal with a budget deficit?

Countries can counter budget deficits by promoting economic growth through fiscal policies, such as reducing government spending and increasing taxes.

Why is it difficult to cut Social Security?

Legal barriers and the structure of the Social Security Trust Fund make it nearly impossible to use cuts in benefits for deficit reduction. The fiscal case for attempting cuts is shaky at best. And there are powerful social and moral reasons to preserve and strengthen Social Security.

Does the government invest Social Security money?

The Social Security Trust Fund receives payroll taxes, pays out benefits, and invests any surplus in special government securities. Those securities earn interest and are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government.

What percentage of people over 50 oppose Social Security?

A full 85 percent of those 50 and over strongly oppose reducing Social Security and Medicare to help reduce the federal budget deficit. While older Americans care about the nation’s long-term fiscal health, we also know they want to make sure the promises made to all Americans regarding Social Security and Medicare are honored.

What is the only income protection for older people?

Social Security is the only inflation-protected, guaranteed source of income people can count on when they retire. It is the principal source of income for more than 34 million older households, and roughly 10 million individuals age 65 and older depend on it for nearly all of their income. Medicare provides the critical health coverage ...

Do Americans get Social Security and Medicare?

Americans have earned their Social Security and Medicare benefits after years of working and paying taxes into the two programs. These programs are critical to tens of millions of workers and retirees who rightfully expect Congress to be careful stewards of their earned benefits.

Can you participate in AmeriSpeak surveys?

Households without conventional internet access but having web access via smartphones are allowed to participate in AmeriSpeak surveys by web. AmeriSpeak panelists participate in NORC studies or studies conducted by NORC on behalf of governmental agencies, academic researchers, and media and commercial organizations.

King of debt no more

This was not how it was supposed to work, according to Trump, when he was running for President in 2016.

Democrats and debt

But this leads to another really important point. Trump exploded the deficit, but Democrats aren’t exactly making the deficit and the debt the most important issues of 2020. Why? Because while they would nearly all like to raise taxes on wealthy Americans, they’d also like the government to spend more money, too.

Why is Social Security called Social Insurance?

Ball, a past Commissioner of Social Security, the Social Security Program is “social insurance” designed to help people “when earnings stop because one is too old to work or too disabled to work, or because the wage earner in the family dies, or because there is no job to be had, or when there are extraordinary expenses connected say with illness.” The Motley Fool echoes this sentiment, saying that Social Security isn’t a retirement plan, but rather is a universal insurance program that protects workers, retirees, and their families from life’s unknowns.

How much did Social Security receive in 2012?

Social Security received more than $725 billion in taxes in 2012, a number that is likely to increase as more people return to work and income levels rise. The Social Security program is analogous to a large lake that provides water to a community.

What would happen if interest rates increased to 5%?

If interest rates increased to 5%, the market value of the bond would fall to $500 – a 50% loss – since an investor could buy a new bond and earn 5%. Social Security Treasuries are guaranteed redeemable at face value even if they are redeemed early.

When was Social Security created?

Social Security was created on August 14, 1935 when President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the Social Security Act and has been controversial since its beginning. A Cato Institute commentary compared Social Security to Otto von Bismarck’s welfare state in Germany, calling it a “Ponzi scheme, with new contributions used to pay off earlier ‘investors.'” The author of the Cato commentary, Marc Rudov, doubles down his criticism in a second American Thinker article, stating that “Social Security is irreversibly insolvent.” These negative statements assume that future beneficiaries will receive no benefits or will receive payments less than their contributions because their contributions are being used to support current beneficiaries.

Does Social Security add to the federal deficit?

Social Security Is a Major Factor in the Nation’s Annual Deficit & Debt. Social Security payments do not add to the federal deficit or debt, despite conservative politicians’ claims.

Is Social Security a perfect system?

Is our Social Security system perfect? No , but our leaders agree that the Social Security program, in the words of Dwight D. Eisenhower, is “vital to the economic security of the American people.” Harry S. Truman once stated that it “is neither a dole nor a device for giving people something for nothing, but earned and guaranteed by the law of the land.” And President John F. Kennedy said on June 30, 1961, “The Social Security program plays an important part in providing for families, children, and older persons in times of stress. But it cannot remain static. Changes in our population, in our working habits, and in our standard of living require constant revision.”

Is Social Security going bankrupt?

Social Security Is Going Bankrupt. Vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan stated that “Medicare and Social Security are going bankrupt” in the 2012 vice presidential debate. However, his statement (and similar comments by conservative politicians) is untrue, as it ignores the program’s annual revenues.

Why do people support budget reform?

A lot of people support budget process reform because they don’t want to deal with the underlying policy issue of what to do with spending and revenues. On the other hand, it could have profound effects.

Who is the president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget?

As president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, MacGuineas leads an organization that helps analyze and develop policies to control deficit spending and the nation’s federal debt, which is the accumulation of all our deficits over time.

Is the Trust Act a bipartisan bill?

The [TRUST Act] is supported by a number of bipartisan, bicameral leaders who are fed up with ki cking the can and ignoring the major problems in our largest programs such as Social Security and Medicare. Along these lines, there have been a number of proposals to change how we do federal budgeting.

image
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9