Medicare Blog

why is medicare a more progressive program than social security?

by Vinnie Walter IV Published 2 years ago Updated 1 year ago

Taxes – For sure, Medicare is a progressive plan ! Some politicos and pundits say that payroll taxes — the paycheck deductions that fund Medicare and Social Security are regressive taxes — with high earners paying lower rates than low earners.

Full Answer

Is Medicare progressive or progressive?

When the Medicare program is considered in its totality — contributions and benefits — it’s clearly progressive — with high earners paying way more for the same benefits that low earners get. The Medicare Program was introduced in 1966.

What is the difference between social security and Medicare?

And because each program offers unique benefits, it’s important to know the differences between the two. SS and Medicare are similar, but not the same. The SSA determines who’s eligible for Medicare and handles some of Medicare’s administrative duties, like enrollment.

Is Medicare a regressive tax?

Some politicos and pundits say that payroll taxes — the paycheck deductions that fund Medicare and Social Security are regressive taxes — with high earners paying lower rates than low earners. For Medicare, they point out that that the same tax rate is applied to both high and low wages — the definition of a regressive tax. First, no it isn’t.

What is Social Security and how does it work?

Social Security was designed to redistribute income from those with higher lifetime earnings to those with lower lifetime earnings. The reason is obvious: the system was created to ensure an adequate retirement income for the elderly.

How does Medicare differ from Social Security?

Social Security offers retirement, disability, and survivors benefits. Medicare provides health insurance. Because these services are often related, you may not know which agency to contact for help.

Are Social Security benefits progressive?

Social Security benefits are progressive: they represent a higher proportion of a worker's previous earnings for workers at lower earnings levels. Social Security benefits are progressive: they represent a higher proportion of a worker's previous earnings for workers at lower earnings levels.

What is so great about Medicare?

Medicare guarantees affordable health insurance. Medicare delivers a guaranteed level of coverage to people who might not otherwise be able to afford it. And it helps insulate beneficiaries from rising health care costs.

What is the relationship between Medicare and Social Security?

Social Security provides financial support, and Medicare is a health insurance program that helps cover doctor visits, hospital stays and other medical treatments. While the programs are separate, Social Security and Medicare are intertwined in several ways.

Is Social Security progressive or regressive?

regressive taxThe Social Security tax is a regressive tax, meaning that a larger portion of lower-income earners' total income is withheld, compared with that of higher-income earners.

Is Social Security is an example of a progressive tax?

For people with lower than average earnings, the ratio of the lifetime benefits they receive from Social Security to the lifetime payroll taxes they pay for the program is higher than it is for people with higher average earnings. In that sense, the Social Security system is progressive.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of Medicare?

The takeaway Medicare Advantage offers many benefits to original Medicare, including convenient coverage, multiple plan options, and long-term savings. There are some disadvantages as well, including provider limitations, additional costs, and lack of coverage while traveling.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of Medicare for All?

Though Medicare for All would likely lower the healthcare costs in the economy overall and increase quality care while also facilitating more preventative care to avoid expensive emergency room visits, you could end up paying more if you make more than $250,000 a year or are in the top 0.1 % of households.

What is the difference between Social Security and Medicare quizlet?

In the U.S, Social Security is a social insurance program created to aid individuals in retirement or those that have become disabled. Medicare is a social insurance program focused on providing medical insurance to individuals 65 or older, or who meet specific criteria.

Does Medicare reduce Social Security?

In fact, if you are signed up for both Social Security and Medicare Part B — the portion of Medicare that provides standard health insurance — the Social Security Administration will automatically deduct the premium from your monthly benefit.

Can you collect Social Security without Medicare?

Yes, many people receive Social Security without signing up for Medicare. Most people aren't eligible for Medicare until they turn 65. As you can start collecting Social Security retirement benefits at 62, individuals may have Social Security without Medicare for several years.

America's indispensable healthcare program for seniors may exhaust its cash reserves in 12 years, which is five years earlier than Social Security

For millions of Americans, Social Security is arguably the most important social program. Data from the Social Security Administration shows that 61% of all retired workers count on their monthly Social Security check to account for at least half of their income. Without this income, millions of additional seniors would likely be living in poverty.

Medicare is in deep trouble

However, when push comes to shove, Medicare is actually in worse shape than Social Security. Medicare covered nearly 57 million people in 2016, of which roughly five out of six are senior citizens aged 65 or older.

What happens if Medicare exhausts its asset reserves?

So, what happens if Medicare runs out of its asset reserves? According to the predictions from the Board of Trustees, reimbursements to hospitals and physicians would drop by 12% to 88% of their current levels.

Consider an alternative

In one sense, the American public has to hope that Congress gets its act together and fixes Medicare soon. As with Social Security, the longer lawmakers wait to act, the costlier it will be to fix. However, we can't simply rely on Capitol Hill to fix our problems. Instead, seniors have to be willing to weigh their options.

Premium Investing Services

Invest better with the Motley Fool. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from the Motley Fool's premium services.

Who determines who is eligible for Medicare?

The SSA determines who’s eligible for Medicare and handles some of Medicare’s administrative duties, like enrollment. That’s why people enroll in Medicare by contacting the SSA.

Is Medicare the same as SS?

And because each program offers unique benefits, it’s important to know the differences between the two. SS and Medicare are similar, but not the same.

When was Medicare introduced?

The Medicare Program was introduced in 1966 . It is primarily “our country’s health insurance program for people age 65 or older” — “helping” to pay (i.e. not paying all) for hospital services & stays, doctors, medical supplies, and prescription drugs. The latter is courtesy of the Bush administration.

How much is Medicare contribution?

Employers are obligated to match employees’ Medicare contributions dollar-for-dollar. So, the combined Medicare contribution is 2.9% — half paid by employees and half paid by employers. Since self-employed folks are both employers and employees, that get docked for the full 2.9%

Is Social Security regressive or regressive?

Some politicos and pundits say that payroll taxes — the paycheck deductions that fund Medicare and Social Security are regressive taxes — with high earners paying lower rates than low earners.

Is Medicare regressive or progressive?

There’s no way that anybody can say with a straight face that the Medicare portion of “payroll taxes” is regressive? It’s progressive — in fact, very progressive. PERIOD !

Is Medicare progressive?

When the Medicare program is considered in its totality — contributions and benefits — it’s clearly progressive — with high earners paying way more for the same benefits that low earners get.

Is Medicare the same for all?

Again, keep in mind that Medicare benefits are identical for all — regardless of how much was paid into the program over the course of a wage earner’s career.

Does Medicare cover long term care?

The program helps with the cost of health care, but it does not cover all medical expenses or the cost of most long-term care.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9