why is medicare reimbursement so bad for surgeons

Surgeons contend with high fixed costs and debt, and now face plummeting revenue. Over the last 20 years, the costs of being a surgeon have increased while Medicare’s surgical payments have not only failed to keep up with inflation but have actually declined in nominal terms.

Full Answer

Will Medicare payments for surgeons see Medicare patients drop?

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently proposed that, beginning January 1, payments for surgeons seeing Medicare patients be cut, declining, for instance, by 9% for cardiac surgery, 8% for thoracic surgery and 7% for vascular surgery.

How does a doctor’s participating in Medicare affect reimbursement?

Q: How does a doctor’s participating in Medicare affect reimbursement? A: Medicare reimbursement refers to the payments that hospitals and physicians receive in return for services rendered to Medicare beneficiaries.

Do Medicare and Medicaid pay for surgical procedures differently?

Using commercials as a reference, Medicare and Medicaid pay only 7 and 13 percent less, respectively, for office visits than commercial insurers do; for hospital visits the disparities are 22 and 35 percent. The public programs apparently are relatively less generous for inpatient services, and this also shows up in the surgical procedures.

What does it mean when a hospital is reimbursed by Medicare?

A: Medicare reimbursement refers to the payments that hospitals and physicians receive in return for services rendered to Medicare beneficiaries. The reimbursement rates for these services are set by Medicare, and are typically less than the amount billed or the amount that a private insurance company would pay.

Does Medicare pay doctors less?

Fee reductions by specialty Summarizing, we do find corroborative evidence (admittedly based on physician self-reports) that both Medicare and Medicaid pay significantly less (e.g., 30-50 percent) than the physician's usual fee for office and inpatient visits as well as for surgical and diagnostic procedures.

Why do doctors not like Medicare?

Can Doctors Refuse Medicare? The short answer is "yes." Thanks to the federal program's low reimbursement rates, stringent rules, and grueling paperwork process, many doctors are refusing to accept Medicare's payment for services. Medicare typically pays doctors only 80% of what private health insurance pays.

Why do doctors complain about reimbursement rates?

In many markets, commercial plans may pay slightly above the Medicare rates, while doctors say that many of the new exchange plans are offering rates below that. Physicians are uncomfortable discussing their rates because of antitrust laws, and insurers say the information is proprietary.

Does a surgical procedure affect Medicare reimbursement?

Medicare Part B covers payments to providers for services and procedures, as well as any outpatient care required during postsurgical follow-up.

Do doctors treat Medicare patients differently?

Many doctors try to help out patients who can't afford to pay the full amount for an office visit or the copay for a pricey medication. Now along comes a study suggesting that physicians in one Texas community treat patients differently, depending on whether they are on Medicare or have private insurance.

What percentage of doctors do not accept Medicare?

Only 1 percent of non-pediatric physicians have formally opted-out of the Medicare program. As of September 2020, 9,541 non-pediatric physicians have opted out of Medicare, representing a very small share (1.0 percent) of the total number active physicians, similar to the share reported in 2013.

Why do surgeons get paid so much?

The median wage for American surgeons in 2010 was $166,400 USD a year. One of the main reasons that doctors are paid as well as they are is because their services are absolutely essential. They may work long, very busy days and treat a range of people with different needs.

Why so many doctors are broke?

The short definition is doctors spend so many years borrowing money to live on during training, that they have become numb to the deleterious effects of debt. Doctors in training continually borrow money, throw it onto the debt pile, and notice that nothing bad happens.

Why are doctors underpaid?

2:0713:58Why DOCTORS are UNDERPAID - YouTubeYouTubeStart of suggested clipEnd of suggested clipHere because junior doctors are contracted for 48. Hours a week as opposed to 40 or 37 48 hours aMoreHere because junior doctors are contracted for 48. Hours a week as opposed to 40 or 37 48 hours a week what that's like two days of work in the u.s.

What affects Medicare reimbursement?

Average reimbursements per beneficiary enrolled in the program depend upon the percentage of enrolled persons who exceed the deductible and receive reimbursements, the average allowed charge per service, and the number of services used.

Does Medicare reimbursement differ by state?

Over the years, program data have indicated that although Medicare has uniform premiums and deductibles, benefits paid out vary significantly by State of residence of the beneficiary. These variations are due in part to the fact that reimbursements are based on local physicians' prices.

What is the two midnight rule?

The Two-Midnight rule, adopted in October 2013 by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, states that more highly reimbursed inpatient payment is appropriate if care is expected to last at least two midnights; otherwise, observation stays should be used.

What is a Medicare participating provider?

Physicians who agree to fully accept the rates set by Medicare are referred to as participating providers. They accept Medicare’s reimbursements fo...

What is a non-participating Medicare provider?

Because the reimbursement rates are generally lower than physicians receive from private insurance carriers, some physicians opt to be non-particip...

What is a Medicare opt-out provider?

A small number of doctors (less than 1 percent of eligible physicians) opt out of Medicare entirely, meaning that they do not accept Medicare reimb...

Do surgeons have to pay higher fixed costs?

Surgeons contend with high fixed costs and debt, and now face plummeting revenue. Over the last 20 years, the costs of being a surgeon have increased while Medicare’s surgical payments have not only failed to keep up with inflation but have actually declined in nominal terms.

Is telehealth a replacement for surgical care?

But telehealth is no replacement for surgical care, and the health care system simply cannot absorb cuts of this magnitude right now.

What factors go into determining Medicare physician compensation?

A number of factors go into determining overall Medicare physician compensation, such as the number of RVUs assigned to a given service; however, without an overall realistic update in place, payments will continue to lose ground to inflation.

What factors affect physician payment?

Another factor that could affect physician payment is potential changes to office/outpatient E/M codes. In the calendar year (CY) 2019 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) final rule, CMS set forth a policy that would have combined levels 2–4 new E/M codes, and paid physicians at a blended rate of the previous E/M code levels starting in CY 2021. But in the CY 2020 MPFS proposed rule, CMS proposed a dramatically different change to E/Ms that would instead maintain the separate levels, but increase the values of E/Ms, again starting in CY 2021. Unfortunately, this current proposal will not apply the increased E/M values to the E/M values incorporated into global codes. At this time there is great uncertainty regarding how CMS will move forward, but there is a strong likelihood that potential increased payments for E/Ms will shift payment from surgery to primary care, given budget neutrality requirements for physician payment.

What penalties did MACRA eliminate?

In addition, MACRA eliminated penalties associated with prior Medicare quality programs, such as the Physician Quality Reporting System (PQRS), the EHR Incentive Program, and the Value-based Payment Modifier.

How is Medicare reimbursement calculated?

For a given service or bundle of services, the relative value units (RVUs) assigned to that service are multiplied by a dollar amount referred to as the conversion factor.

When does Medicare 0 percent expire?

Medicare payment rates are about to enter a six-year period of 0 percent updates, during which early MACRA incentives also are set to expire, meaning many physicians will be faced with lower payment rates based on factors out of their control, not on the quality of care they are providing.

When did Medicare release its annual report?

In April 2019 , Medicare released its 2019 Annual Report of the Boards of Trustees of the Federal Hospital Insurance (HI) and Federal Supplementary Medical Insurance Trust Funds, which analyzed the long-term solvency of Medicare and how depletion of the HI trust fund could affect physician reimbursement over time.

What is the maximum payment update for physicians in 2021?

Physician performance on these measures, along with improvement activities and use of electronic health records (EHRs) in 2019, will result in positive or negative payment adjustment of up to 7 percent in 2021. Next year, the maximum payment update is phased in, meaning that performance in 2020 will result in payment increases or reductions ...

What is Medicare reimbursement?

A: Medicare reimbursement refers to the payments that hospitals and physicians receive in return for services rendered to Medicare beneficiaries. The reimbursement rates for these services are set by Medicare, and are typically less than the amount billed or the amount that a private insurance company would pay.

How many psychiatrists have opted out of Medicare?

Of the tiny fraction of doctors who have opted out of Medicare entirely, 42 percent are psychiatrists. And although the number of doctors opting out increased sharply from 2012 to 2016, it dropped in 2017, with 3,732 doctors opting out.

What is Medicare participating provider?

Physicians who agree to fully accept the rates set by Medicare are referred to as participating providers. They accept Medicare’s reimbursements for all Medicare-covered services, for all Medicare patients, and bill Medicare directly for covered services. Most eligible providers are in this category. A Kaiser Family Foundation analysis found that ...

What happens if you don't accept assignment for treatment?

If you receive treatment from a non-participating provider who doesn’t accept assignment for the treatment you receive, you may have to pay the bill up front and seek reimbursement from Medicare for the portion they’ll pay.

Does Medicare pay for the entire bill?

If a Medicare beneficiary receives services from one of these doctors, the patient must pay the entire bill; Medicare will not reimburse the doctor or the patient for any portion of the bill, and the provider can set whatever fees they choose.

Can a doctor opt out of Medicare?

A small number of doctors (less than 1 percent of eligible physicians) opt out of Medicare entirely, meaning that they do not accept Medicare reimbursement as payment-in-full for any services, for any Medicare patients. If a Medicare beneficiary receives services from one of these doctors, the patient must pay the entire bill;

Can a physician accept Medicare reimbursement?

Because the reimbursement rates are generally lower than physicians receive from private insurance carriers, some physicians opt to be non-participating providers. This means that they haven’t signed a contract agreeing to accept Medicare reimbursement as payment-in-full for all services, but they can agree to accept Medicare reimbursement ...

What happens if you see a doctor in your insurance network?

If you see a doctor in your plan’s network, your doctor will handle the claims process. Your doctor will only charge you for deductibles, copayments, or coinsurance. However, the situation is different if you see a doctor who is not in your plan’s network.

What to do if a pharmacist says a drug is not covered?

You may need to file a coverage determination request and seek reimbursement.

How long does it take for Medicare to process a claim?

Medicare claims to providers take about 30 days to process. The provider usually gets direct payment from Medicare. What is the Medicare Reimbursement fee schedule? The fee schedule is a list of how Medicare is going to pay doctors. The list goes over Medicare’s fee maximums for doctors, ambulance, and more.

Does Medicare cover out of network doctors?

Coverage for out-of-network doctors depends on your Medicare Advantage plan. Many HMO plans do not cover non-emergency out-of-network care, while PPO plans might. If you obtain out of network care, you may have to pay for it up-front and then submit a claim to your insurance company.

Do participating doctors accept Medicare?

Most healthcare doctors are “participating providers” that accept Medicare assignment. They have agreed to accept Medicare’s rates as full payment for their services. If you see a participating doctor, they handle Medicare billing, and you don’t have to file any claim forms.

Do you have to pay for Medicare up front?

But in a few situations, you may have to pay for your care up-front and file a claim asking Medicare to reimburse you. The claims process is simple, but you will need an itemized receipt from your provider.

Do you have to ask for reimbursement from Medicare?

If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, you will never have to ask for reimbursement from Medicare. Medicare pays Advantage companies to handle the claims. In some cases, you may need to ask the company to reimburse you. If you see a doctor in your plan’s network, your doctor will handle the claims process.

What is Medicare reimbursement?

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (CMS) sets reimbursement rates for all medical services and equipment covered under Medicare. When a provider accepts assignment, they agree to accept Medicare-established fees. Providers cannot bill you for the difference between their normal rate and Medicare set fees.

How much does Medicare pay?

Medicare pays for 80 percent of your covered expenses. If you have original Medicare you are responsible for the remaining 20 percent by paying deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. Some people buy supplementary insurance or Medigap through private insurance to help pay for some of the 20 percent.

What does it mean when a provider is not a participating provider?

If the provider is not a participating provider, that means they don’t accept assignment. They may accept Medicare patients, but they have not agreed to accept the set Medicare rate for services.

What is Medicare Part D?

Medicare Part D or prescription drug coverage is provided through private insurance plans. Each plan has its own set of rules on what drugs are covered. These rules or lists are called a formulary and what you pay is based on a tier system (generic, brand, specialty medications, etc.).

What happens if you see an out of network provider?

Depending on the circumstances, if you see an out-of-network provider, you may have to file a claim to be reimbursed by the plan. Be sure to ask the plan about coverage rules when you sign up. If you were charged for a covered service, you can contact the insurance company to ask how to file a claim.

Is Medicare Advantage private or public?

Medicare Advantage or Part C works a bit differently since it is private insurance. In addition to Part A and Part B coverage, you can get extra coverage like dental, vision, prescription drugs, and more.

Do providers have to file a claim for Medicare?

They agree to accept CMS set rates for covered services. Providers will bill Medicare directly, and you don’t have to file a claim for reimbursement.

What is Medicare reimbursement based on?

Reimbursement is based on the DRGs and procedures that were assigned and performed during the patient’s hospital stay. Each DRG is assigned a cost based on the average cost based on previous visits. This assigned cost provides a simple method for Medicare to reimburse hospitals as it is only a simple flat rate based on the services provided.

How much higher is Medicare approved?

The amount for each procedure or test that is not contracted with Medicare can be up to 15 percent higher than the Medicare approved amount. In addition, Medicare will only reimburse patients for 95 percent of the Medicare approved amount.

How many DRGs can be assigned to a patient?

Each DRG is based on a specific primary or secondary diagnosis, and these groups are assigned to a patient during their stay depending on the reason for their visit. Up to 25 procedures can impact the specific DRG that is assigned to a patient, and multiple DRGs can be assigned to a patient during a single stay.

What is Medicare Part A?

What Medicare Benefits Cover Hospital Expenses? Medicare Part A is responsible for covering hospital expenses when a Medicare recipient is formally admitted. Part A may include coverage for inpatient surgeries, recovery from surgery, multi-day hospital stays due to illness or injury, or other inpatient procedures.

How much extra do you have to pay for Medicare?

This means that the patient may be required to pay up to 20 percent extra in addition to their standard deductible, copayments, coinsurance payments, and premium payments. While rare, some hospitals completely opt out of Medicare services.

Does Medicare cover permanent disability?

Medicare provides coverage for millions of Americans over the age of 65 or individuals under 65 who have certain permanent disabilities. Medicare recipients can receive care at a variety of facilities, and hospitals are commonly used for emergency care, inpatient procedures, and longer hospital stays. Medicare benefits often cover care ...

Is Medicare reimbursement lower than private insurance?

This is mainly due to the fact that Medicare reimbursement amounts are often lower than those received from private insurance companies . For these providers, the patient may be required to pay for the full cost of the visit up front and can then seek personal reimbursement from Medicare afterwards.

What is Medicare for disabled people?

Medicare is a federal program to reimburse medical costs in people who are disabled, have kidney failure, or are elderly. Under Medicare, the government determines reimbursement rates. If your favorite orthopedic surgeon takes care of Medicare enrollees, she doesn’t decide how much to charge the government for the care she provides;

Is Medicare fee uniform across the country?

Medicare fees are not uniform across the country. The government takes account of local cost of living, for example, in determining payment rate; consequently, Medicare fees are higher in San Francisco than in Oklahoma City.

Do people with complicated life circumstances have more complications after joint replacement surgery?

As it turns out, patients with lots of other medical problems, and those with complicated life circumstances, are more likely to experience complications after joint replacement surgeries, and also more likely to report low satisfaction with the procedures.

Do orthopedic surgeons get less money from Medicare?

The greater the proportion of low-income patients that orthopedic surgeons care for, the less money they receive from Medicare to reward them for high quality of care. Here's a summary of that finding, with healthcare providers split into quintiles. At the top are the providers with the smallest percent of low-income patients.

The Conversion Factor and Cost Containment

Other Factors Affecting Surgeon Compensation

• The conversion factor is just one part of the physician compensation equation. Other factors include the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS), difficulties in developing A-APMs, and ever-evolving evaluation and management (E/M) codes.

See more on bulletin.facs.org

Medicare Solvency and Effects on Future Physician Reimbursement

MedPAC Report to Congress

ACS Advocacy Efforts

Acknowledgment