how does dispariy between asc and hospital surgery centers affect medicare

by Anderson Nikolaus Published 3 years ago Updated 2 years ago

For ASCs, surgeries are coded based on procedures, while for hospitals, they are line-item-based. ASCs also use the claim forms prescribed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for claims from physicians—CMS-1500 forms and uniform billing (UB) forms.

Full Answer

How does Medicare pay for ASC procedures compare to hopd?

Aug 05, 2014 · The availability of ASC care is not the only difference in Medicare coverage. Medicare reimburses ASCs for the exact same procedures at much lower rates than it reimburses hospitals, despite CMS’ admission that the market baskets (variables including time, facilities, …

How much do ASCs reduce health care costs?

Jul 21, 2009 · ASCs provide a lower cost alternative to hospitals for the provision of surgical services. [ 11 – 13] Medicare increased this cost advantage for more procedures under new reimbursement guidelines instituted in January 2008. [ 11]

How many hospitals own ASCs?

Today, procedures performed in the ASC cost Medicare just 53% of the amount paid to HOPDs. For example, Medicare pays hospitals $1,745 for performing an outpatient cataract surgery while paying ASCs only $976 for performing the same surgery. Beneficiary savings are also significant:

What's behind the ASC and hopd reimbursement gap?

Dec 13, 2012 · Posted December 13, 2012 by Jason Beans. Outpatient surgery in an Ambulatory Surgery Center (ASC) costs much less than in an outpatient hospital setting or ASC owned by …

What is the difference between ASC and hospital?

2. What's the Difference Between an Outpatient Hospital and an Ambulatory Surgical Center? The primary difference between an outpatient surgery center — also referred to as an outpatient hospital — and an ASC surgery center is who runs the facility.

Are there any disparities in the delivery of ambulatory care?

However, disparities in the use of ASCs, if evident, are likely to have downstream consequences, including higher expenditures for patients with less ability to afford their care. For this reason, we evaluated the extent to which the use of ASCs varied according to socioeconomic status and race/ethnicity.Jul 21, 2009

How do hospitals compete with freestanding ambulatory surgical centers ASCs?

Freestanding ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) compete directly with hospital outpatient departments (HOPDs) for many medical procedures that can now be performed in an outpatient setting.

How does Medicare reimburse ASC?

Disparate Reimbursement Policies For Hospitals And ASCs

CMS uses the Hospital Outpatient Prospective Payment System to reimburse physicians for surgeries performed at a hospital outpatient department (HOPD), and the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule for surgeries at an ASC.Jun 2, 2021

Why ASCs are better than hospitals?

ASCs have been shown to have greater efficiency with no differences in complication rates compared to HOPDs. A narrower scope of procedures performed in the ASC setting allows for more specialized care and high patient satisfaction due to smaller and more personalized teams.Sep 1, 2019

What is the difference between ASC and HOPD?

An HOPD is owned by and typically attached to a hospital, whereas an ASC is considered a standalone facility.Feb 28, 2020

Why are ASCs cheaper than hospitals?

ASCs do not incur the often substantial administrative and overhead costs associated with a hospital. This enables ASCs to provide these services at substantially less cost to the Medicare program—and to its beneficiaries—than their hospital counterparts.

When a hospital based surgery center is not certified as an ASC the reimbursement rules apply?

If a hospital-based surgery center is not certified as an , it continues under the program as part of a hospital. In that case, the applicable hospital outpatient payment rules apply. This is the outpatient prospective payment system (OPPS), for most hospitals, or may be provisions for hospitals excluded from.May 26, 2021

Does Medicare pay for implants in ASC?

Medicare will make no payment for facility services to ASCs or physicians for procedures or services that are performed in ASCs but that are excluded from the list of covered ASC surgical procedures or that are not covered ancillary services.

What is the ASC reimbursement system?

Payment for ambulatory surgical center (ASC) services is also based on rates set under Medicare Part B. This system for payment is called the ASC Payment System and is used when paying for covered surgical procedures, including ASC facility services that are furnished in connection with the covered surgical procedure.

Abstract

Ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs) provide outpatient surgical services more efficiently than hospital outpatient departments, benefiting patients through lower co-payments and other expenses. We studied the influence of socioeconomic status and race on use of ASCs.

Background

In an effort to lower medical costs and improve the efficiency of health care, [ 1] increasing numbers of surgeries are being performed on an outpatient basis. [ 2] Little data exists to guide the decision as to where a procedure should be performed.

Methods

Using the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality's State Ambulatory Surgery Database for Florida, all ambulatory surgery procedures at both hospital based facilities and ASCs were obtained for 2005. The dataset provides patient level discharge data for 100% of the ambulatory patients from facilities in state. [ 17]

Results

Socioeconomic quintiles were balanced with the number of discharges ranging from 208,557 for the lowest group to 236,385 for the highest group (Table 1 ). The age and racial structures of the cohorts varied significantly with the lowest socioeconomic status groups being younger and more ethnically diverse than the higher groups (Table 2 ).

Discussion

Disadvantaged populations, as measured by zip code level socioeconomic status, are more likely to have outpatient surgery performed in hospitals than in ASCs. Patient race and ethnicity appear to modify the association between socioeconomic status and ASC use.

Conclusion

Regardless of the cause of the disparity, patients of lower socioeconomic status likely encounter a higher cost burden for their care than people from more advantaged neighborhoods. The benefits of ASCs in cost, convenience, and efficiency are not equitably distributed.

Rights and permissions

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License ( http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0 ), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Does Medicare use NCCI?

Medicare, and a few of the large commercial carriers, utilize NCCI edits and many commercial carriers use other edit systems. There is no standardization of edit systems, which makes ASC coding very complex.

When was the first ambulatory surgery center opened?

In 1970 , Drs. Wallace Reed and John Ford opened the nation’s first ambulatory surgery center in Phoenix — the culmination of years of clamoring by providers, public officials and patients for a lower-cost, high-quality alternative to expensive hospital stays for same-day procedures.

What was the effect of the Affordable Care Act?

The Affordable Care Act gave rise to a dramatic expansion of network agreements between providers and payers that create patient volume for hospitals and health systems and stabilize costs for insurance companies.

What is managed care contract?

Managed care contracts are negotiated directly with ASCs, a process that requires knowledge of and experience with the ASC revenue cycle, as well as considerable research to ensure procedures are reimbursed at the correct rates; if not, facilities may wind up accepting cases that have no chance of turning a profit.

What is hospital coding?

Hospital coding typically resembles a laundry list, with every pill, bandage and stitch spelled out related to a patient encounter. ASC coding is typically procedure-based, with a list of approved procedures that can be performed in that setting. ASCs use both CMS 1500 forms and UB forms. ASCs also utilize CPT codes, revenue codes and HCPCS codes.

Is ASC lower than HOPD?

In general, ASCs command lower rates than their HOPD counterparts. Using Medicare as an example, when outpatient surgeries shift from an HOPD setting to a freestanding ASC, the Medicare payment methodology changes from the Outpatient Prospective Payment System (OPPS) to the ASC fee schedule.

What is the most significant contributing factor to ASC growth?

Perhaps the most significant contributing factor of ASC growth is the industrywide push toward value-based care. With health plans pressing for the implementation of value-based payment contracts, ASCs afford providers and administrators a more efficient surgical setting, reducing payer costs. Government payers, organized provider networks, self-funded employer health plans, and other organizations at risk for rising healthcare costs are increasingly encouraging patients to use ASCs.

Medicare Blog